Reason for request
Inclusion on list
Summary of opinion
Favourable opinion for reimbursement only as an adjunct to a reduced-calorie diet and increased physical activity for weight management, including weight loss and weight maintenance, in adults with an initial body mass index (BMI) ≥ 35 kg/m² in the event of failure of well-conducted nutritional management (< 5% weight loss after six months).
Unfavourable opinion for reimbursement in the other situations covered by the MA indication.
Clinical Benefit
| Substantial |
The clinical benefit of MOUNJARO (tirzepatide) is substantial only as an adjunct to a reduced-calorie diet and increased physical activity for weight management, including weight loss and weight maintenance, in adults with an initial body mass index (BMI) ≥ 35 kg/m² in the event of failure of well-conducted nutritional management (< 5% weight loss after six months).
|
| Insufficient |
The clinical benefit of MOUNJARO (tirzepatide) is insufficient to justify public funding in the other MA situations.
|
Clinical Added Value
| minor |
Considering:
- new efficacy data from three placebo-controlled studies conducted in patients with a mean BMI of over 35 kg/m², confirming the substantial efficacy of tirzepatide on weight loss,
- the results of an open-label study that evaluated weight loss with tirzepatide compared to semaglutide, which are difficult to interpret due to methodological limitations,
- results for clinically relevant morbidity endpoints in obese patients, from three studies (SUMMIT, SURMOUNT-OSA, SURMOUNT-1 extension),
- the results of the SUMMIT study concerning patients with heart failure, demonstrating a benefit on a composite endpoint including cardiovascular deaths and worsening of heart failure, which nonetheless did not demonstrate a reduction in cardiovascular deaths,
- the results of the SURMOUNT-OSA study, which demonstrate a benefit for change in apnoea-hypopnoea index,
- the results of the SURMOUNT-1 extension study, which demonstrate a benefit for time to onset of type 2 diabetes in the long term (193 weeks) in patients with prediabetes,
- an improvement of quality of life demonstrated in the SUMMIT study for change in Kansas City Cardiomyopathy Questionnaire Summary Score (KCCQ-CSS),
- the safety profile marked predominantly by gastrointestinal adverse events with, in particular, extensive experience in the SURMOUNT-1 study, with follow-up for up to 193 weeks,
pending the results for the cardiovascular endpoints in the SURMOUNT-MMO study, the Committee deems that MOUNJARO (tirzepatide) provides a minor clinical added value (CAV IV), in the same way as WEGOVY (semaglutide), in the care pathway for adult patients with an initial body mass index (BMI) > 35 kg/m² in the event of failure of well-conducted nutritional management (< 5% weight loss after 6 months) and as an adjunct to a reduced-calorie diet and physical activity.
|
| Not applicable |
|
eNq1mE1z2jAQhu/8Co8PvdnmM0BryLQ0aZlJppSEaaeXjLAXkGskRx+Y5NdXxqQhHXnSCHTEst9d764evTg8365TZwOMY0oGbsOvuw6QiMaYLAfu7PbS67nnw1qYoA06uK3r1/1G03WiFHE+cItVfw6IcP/n9dVnUM8Dc4c1J6TzBCLx4j4pcOp/RXx1jbLiHifcUBw7axArGg/cTIrdVSfkgqkshjllv3mGIgiD/ZXD1eSufXg9DAqx/1CVHNgVIkutKBAjzUgyBkSMkIAlZQ8V+baMtDGfAqeSRTBBYjVhdINjiLUhFijlYBRkkcc3wDYpiCKIVjxIojU3EkcJ2k7hfqxP+qNaHYmt8Opeo9trNFvt5lm/2+4YhWIHpdJ3Qb1EkN21ut2zerMfAAnWVJIEMeoJzB4hQ0KV18sBL1fCsF8TygRKLXUK89HLYbMUh8H9qxMRY56l6MFPeGZaKsSQWgamkGDvRYo3uGUKUqmq2T/6RKZp8MasZ3uEWMq4INRITaWoIMnl1LQQI0oEbKs7agY/sd3PIgZ+OtlHSvTgn8h5iiNTzCkQSeBiNh1XU842ID4hDjNmjxA/MIlpzk9PnsNOW8o+28FTK5qxuHHX7PfOGp2O8cb6pcaq4iS6kIxmECgmYX4MasZkQY+FjJpUvdTTnFod0Z1HohFKocIleYYMUrP5ZOqsTb+9nVUuaEW/XNyajsx3CezhZvdTK43jwd9mmwHaBvXVgL6WeLmVi+TrnV6/1X6H1tmHJ/s9MLTapagVpy2ZnjsrITL+PgjyPPdXiHscqXr6C/a2s+JcW45TlESB+bnD9v4gWDEPpZkqoWwp9Xl52r6ttaab+TV7caxl3j+/t+baGIJJOKIXJfet0Xl8cXrgP/tla2lPXmDHXpidt1XYoMSWv5JzPayPOmJUX8klU4D4tljgig82lXMZBuXHomEtDIoPRcPaHyZAIOM=
SHYYkpbzm4wzTpM0