Reason for request
First listing
Summary of opinion
Favourable opinion for reimbursement for the adjunctive treatment of epileptic seizures associated with cyclin-dependent kinase-like 5 (CDKL5) deficiency disorder (CDD) in patients 2 to 17 years of age, only in the event of drug-resistant epilepsy.
Unfavourable opinion for reimbursement in the other situations covered by the MA indication.
Clinical Benefit
| Moderate |
The Committee deems that the clinical benefit of ZTALMY (ganaxolone) is moderate in the adjunctive treatment of epileptic seizures associated with cyclin-dependent kinase-like 5 (CDKL5) deficiency disorder (CDD) in patients 2 to 17 years of age, only in the event of drug-resistant epilepsy.
|
| Insufficient |
The Committee deems that the clinical benefit of ZTALMY (ganaxolone) is insufficient to justify public funding cover in the other MA situations.
|
Clinical Added Value
| no clinical added value |
Considering:
- demonstration of the superiority of ganaxolone compared to placebo, as adjunctive therapy, in a randomised, double-blind study, on a primary endpoint of variation in the frequency of major motor seizures in the short term (17 weeks), with a modest size effect (median difference of -27.08% in patients with a median number of 49 to 54 seizures per month at baseline), in a context of a high level of drug resistance,
- the substantial medical need to have access to alternatives, due to the limited alternatives in this rare disease,
but in view of:
- the absence of a demonstrated statistically significant difference compared to placebo for the percentage of patients presenting an at least 50% reduction in the number of seizures, a relevant ranked secondary endpoint,
- the absence of robust data on quality of life, which is particularly impacted in this disease,
- the absence of long-term efficacy and safety data for ganaxolone, in the context of a chronic disease,
the Committee considers that ZTALMY (ganaxolone) as adjunctive therapy provides no clinical added value (CAV V) in the treatment of drug-resistant seizures associated with cyclin-dependent kinase-like 5 (CDKL5) deficiency disorder (CDD) in patients 2 to 17 years of age.
|
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
xG391a7Y7YMXuugf